If you want to get published, get ready to face a lot of rejection first. I’m still not published yet, and it’s hard to believe I ever will be based on the number of rejection letters I’ve received. But no matter how many rejection letters you read, you must not give up, or they win! Let your anger spur you on if you must, for mere sorrow will not help you very much.
Nonetheless, I must confess: no matter how much I try to prepare myself, every new rejection letter is like a wooden plank whacking me across the knees and knocking me off my feet. I’d like to say that you get used to it, and maybe you’re someone who will, but me? Never. Every time I’m knocked down, it gets harder to pull myself up. But I keep doing it anyway, because what other option do I have?
Stephen King mentions in his book On Writing that each time he got a rejection letter, he would spear it onto a pike he kept under his bed. I love that idea. I’m not doing anything quite so dramatic, but I am saving all of my rejection letters, and I advise you to do the same. I’m watching the stack grow. On the one hand, it’s not very flattering to look at. But on the other hand, I can look at that stack and feel that with every new rejection letter, I’m getting closer to one of acceptance. I picture the day when I’m published and I can burn all those rejection letters to ashes.
In the hopes of helping you along your own rejection-ridden journey, I’m going to copy some of my many rejection letters for you in this post. If you’re starting the process of trying to get published, you can get an idea here of what to expect. Or, if you’re already trying to get published yourself, you can know you’re not the only one receiving these letters.
In my opinion, the easiest rejections to take are quick and to the point. There’s nothing personal about them, and when it’s your project of migraines and tears that has just been thrown into the trash can, it can be refreshing to know (or at least assume) it had nothing to do with the quality of your work. Here’s a rejection letter I received from Fineprint Literary Management. It didn’t have my name on it, nor even “Dear Author.” It simply said:
Thank you for querying us. I’m afraid we’re swamped with material at present and really not taking on new clients.
I wish you luck in your search for representation.
Regards,
Peter Rubie
I didn’t really shed any tears over that rejection. I just realized they couldn’t fit me into their client list. Time to move on.
What you’ll see more often is a slightly longer rejection letter, apologizing for the fact it’s not personally written. Here is an example from the Irene Goodman Literary Agency.
Dear Author,
We dislike having to send you a standard form letter as much as we’re sure you dislike receiving one. Unfortunately, the volume of unsolicited mail prevents us from giving more individual responses.
We did review your proposal, and unfortunately we are going to pass on representing it.
We appreciate the hard work and diligence needed to get in the door, and since this is a highly subjective business, you may well find success elsewhere. We wish you all the best with your writing.
Regards,
The Irene Goodman Literary Agency
Oddly enough, the longest and sweetest rejection letter I’ve ever received hurt my morale the most. Maybe that’s just me. This was a rejection letter I received from the Larsen Pomada Literary Agency.
Thank you for sharing your work with me. I know that writing a book is a time-consuming and emotional process, so I appreciate the effort you have expended to reach this point in your publishing journey. Alas, I must reject what you have been kind enough to submit.
Like the rest of the arts, publishing is a very subjective business. Even though the founders of the agency have written or coauthored 14 books, most of which have been successful, they still get rejected from time to time. And although we have sold books to more than 100 publishers since 1972, some of our clients’ work is still rejected. Nor do all of the books that we sell succeed. These are the realities of the publishing industry.
Michael, Elizabeth and I are eager to find new books and writers, and we love to get excited about them. But the only way we can make a living is by selling books to the large and medium-sized New York publishers, and selling books by new writers to big publishers is becoming more difficult.
Like editors, we receive thousands of submissions a year and reject more than ninety percent of them. This forces us to use a form letter. But rejecting manuscripts that become successful books is a publishing tradition.
Assume I’m wrong. Persevere until your books reach the goals you set for them. I can’t suggest a publisher or an agent who might be interested in a particular writer’s work, but directories, your publishing network, and the Association of Authors’ Representatives might lead you to the agent you need. Persistence rewards talent. I can’t make a living saying no, but as author Joe Girard says: “Every no gets you closer to yes.”
I wish you the best of luck with your writing career. Our website has information you may find helpful—-www.larsenpomada.com.
–
Larsen Pomada Literary Agents
Office: 1029 Jones Street, San Francisco, CA 94109
Cleary, she is a kind woman trying to write a kind rejection letter. No one can fault her for that. We writers are fragile creatures. So fragile that when I read this letter, it tore me up inside. I had faced so many rejections already and continue to face so many rejections still, I didn’t need someone who didn’t appreciate me to tell me to keep on trucking. I prefer to think of my rejectors as my enemies in order to find the strength to keep going, like these submissions are battles in an ongoing war. So this felt like my enemy was reaching out and patting my head, saying “There there, kiddo, cheer up. Way to go writing a book! That’s wonderful! Now run along and leave me alone.” I don’t know. It just upset me. But obviously she is a nice agent, and I am sure it is wonderful to work with her. *Sigh.*
In contrast, the most encouraging rejection I’ve ever received came from the Writers of the Future Contest. I submit my novellas to that contest quite often and I’ve never won. I’ve seen the rejection letter many times. But one day, I received it in the mail with some changes made.
Dear Contestant Jayden, (she wrote my name in by hand!)
Your story did not win in the 2nd Quarter of the Contest, (ending 31 March 2009).
You still have time to submit a story for the next quarter ending on the 30th of June and I do hope you are in the process of writing it already or have already sent it in.
The judges always stress to our winners and contestants that you should write as much as possible.
I look forward to seeing your next entry.
Best regards, Joni Labqui, Contest Director. (Personally signed!)
And then, handwritten below was: Submit another story soon!
The fact that the director of this contest had gone through the trouble of writing a note on my rejection form made me feel like I’d gotten through to her. It was like she wanted me to win, but my previous submission just wasn’t what she was looking for. It spurred me on to write the best science fiction novella I’ve ever written.
But guess what? It didn’t win.
I’ve now come to terms with the possibility she might have personally written on several rejection letters, just to encourage people. All I know is that she had never done that before and hasn’t done it since. Nevertheless … that was definitely my favorite rejection letter.
I have received a few other personally written rejections. They were all very brief and said something like “Your story failed to pull me in.” Nothing helpful or encouraging at all. Still, I appreciated their effort at human-to-human contact amidst their busy schedules.
Hope that helps.
–Jayden Woods
December 10, 2009
Categories: Publishing . Tags: letter, novel, Publishing, rejection, Writing . Author: jaydenwoods . Comments: Leave a Comment